James

By Pentadact


Games

 

Television

 

Films

 

Music

 

Links

 

Personal

 
 

About

 
 
Let Tom Francis tell you all what it's like, being male, middle-class and white.
 

 

Subscribe

 
 
All Posts
Games
Television
Films
Music
Links
Personal
Comments
 

Nick Montfort On Portal Vs The Passage

 
 

“There are really two big ideas in these two games: The passage of a person through life and the idea that takes control by default in the other, the passage of SKUs through retail stores.” Oh come on.

Nick’s a great writer (mainly of interactive fiction), but it’s like he picked his words specifically to be wrong on as many counts as possible here. Portal was the only unknown name in a package with four huge titles, and Valve have just spent ten years devoting their entire company to finding a way to avoid retail stores.

In general his point seems to be that The Passage is superior and will be remembered longer because it has a message, whereas Portal doesn’t. But the Passage doesn’t have a message - both its creator and Nick himself stress repeatedly that it doesn’t try to push any particular agenda on you, instead leaving you to draw your own conclusions.

I just played it for the first time today. I thought it was a great argument for the case that games can be art, and a great argument for why that isn’t really an interesting, important or fun thing for them to be. Compared to what entertainment has become, compared to Portal, art is just dull, and crude, and passé.

Thanks to Graham for the link.

Link   Comment
 
 
ImperialCreed: I'm sorry, Passage is better than Portal? I think you have it right on Tom with your final comment - Passage is obtuse, ugly and not really a game. Plus with that stupid midi tune it comes across with a tinge of "emo". And nobody likes emo. I played it when it showed up on RPS and it intrigued me a little, but the thought of going back to it now just bores me.

Essentially, Portal is the one game ever I've raved about to anyone who'll listen. I mean, you won't see the likes of John Walker wasting his time painting a silly little sprite on his freezer will you?

Kenny: Yeah, last line sums it up. Just played Passage there and it isn't a real game. It's not in the slightest bit entertaining and I wouldn't even call it art or thought provoking. A waste of time is the best way I can descirbe it.

 
 

Comment

 
 





 
 

Slim Mode

 
 
An unknown php script is randomly causing 15-second chokings of my server's CPU, ultimately hogging so much of its time that my host suspend this entire website for a few minutes. So I've snipped all non-essential elements until I can diagnose it. Apologies if you've encountered one of these CPU Exceeded screens. Believe it or not, what would help most with my diagnosis is lots and lots of people visiting James as often as possible over the next few days. Rolo desserts are also effective.